Search
Most active topics
Latest topics
» Fathers of the Revolutionby joecool Yesterday at 3:13 pm
» Veteran's Day
by joecool November 12th 2024, 5:54 pm
» Nov 2024 Thread
by Claymore November 8th 2024, 7:05 pm
» Vacation Bible School
by joecool November 4th 2024, 5:14 pm
» October 2024 Thread
by joecool November 3rd 2024, 4:51 pm
» Web Wednesday
by joecool October 29th 2024, 10:22 am
» Culture Rot
by joecool October 28th 2024, 10:25 am
» Historical Antiques
by joecool October 26th 2024, 5:34 pm
» Big (Step-) Brother
by joecool October 25th 2024, 11:23 am
Statistics
We have 119 registered usersThe newest registered user is tbullock@rolva.org
Our users have posted a total of 17463 messages in 1036 subjects
If you could have a outpost your way what would you want it to look like?
+3
Claymore
ccm2361
Mark Jones
7 posters
Page 2 of 2
Page 2 of 2 • 1, 2
Re: If you could have a outpost your way what would you want it to look like?
(From "No Input from Springfield Headquarters")
JoeCool's first line of this answer strikes close to the mark.
In Doug Marsh's address to the Royal Rangers Leaders, back in about 2008 (plus or minus a year or two), he indicated that he was receiving unwanted feedback involving the changes that he was implementing to the Program. His words to those local Commanders and Senior Commanders were, "GET ON BOARD, OR GET OFF THE BUS".
And that, apparently, was his goal: to get the old leaders who saw problems with his "Gee-Whiz" changes - - much of it, because they knew what it took to run a ground-level outpost in AMERICA. (Remember that Doug Marsh came from South America, and I do not know if he ever was a local commander, here in the U.S.).
Anyway, without trying to be overly critical, He successfully drove off much of the talent of the Level I Leaders in the Program.
A few years ago, I called a National Muzzleloading Instructor to set up certification training. When I told him that it was for a Royal Ranger Outpost, he said, "Royal Rangers. Oh yeah, I used to be a Royal Rangers Commander. I could handle the changes under Mariott, but not this current fella (Doug Marsh).".
So what I am getting at is, if I personally heard this from two or three or four leaders, how many hundreds (or more) did they drive off? And what's worse is, they didn't have a waiting supply of leaders to replace those that they drove off.
Now was this, alone, the factor that pushed Rangers over the cliff? No, but it was one more unnecessary problem that could have been avoided, with a little bit of wisdom, foresight, and humility.......and listening to your front-line leaders.
joecool wrote:Claymore wrote: “Ignore your troops, and they’ll go away.”
Post-Marsh, how many men would have stepped in to try and fix Royal Rangers? Not me. I'm not a glutton for punishment. I appreciate that someone did, but there was just so much to fix, it was likely overwhelming. No doubt, some of the fluff from that era was never going to be allowed to go away, due to the amount of financial investment in it. Yet, that has cost us a whole lot more, year after year. Why keep adding layers of paint when you haven't dealt with the underlying corrosion?
I think it's in the revitalized 9-year old thread, but someone said that we need to go back to what worked. Johnnie Barnes' creation was nothing short of anointed brilliance. Now we have waaaaaaaaay too many administrative layers, adult medals, training courses, books and more. KISS. Keep It Simple and Sensible.
My LMA courses and instructors were awesome and inspired me to 30 years of RR service. I'd love to do another decade. But the District's RR command structure is long gone. And it appears that pastors have moved on. How to get them back onboard?
JoeCool's first line of this answer strikes close to the mark.
In Doug Marsh's address to the Royal Rangers Leaders, back in about 2008 (plus or minus a year or two), he indicated that he was receiving unwanted feedback involving the changes that he was implementing to the Program. His words to those local Commanders and Senior Commanders were, "GET ON BOARD, OR GET OFF THE BUS".
And that, apparently, was his goal: to get the old leaders who saw problems with his "Gee-Whiz" changes - - much of it, because they knew what it took to run a ground-level outpost in AMERICA. (Remember that Doug Marsh came from South America, and I do not know if he ever was a local commander, here in the U.S.).
Anyway, without trying to be overly critical, He successfully drove off much of the talent of the Level I Leaders in the Program.
A few years ago, I called a National Muzzleloading Instructor to set up certification training. When I told him that it was for a Royal Ranger Outpost, he said, "Royal Rangers. Oh yeah, I used to be a Royal Rangers Commander. I could handle the changes under Mariott, but not this current fella (Doug Marsh).".
So what I am getting at is, if I personally heard this from two or three or four leaders, how many hundreds (or more) did they drive off? And what's worse is, they didn't have a waiting supply of leaders to replace those that they drove off.
Now was this, alone, the factor that pushed Rangers over the cliff? No, but it was one more unnecessary problem that could have been avoided, with a little bit of wisdom, foresight, and humility.......and listening to your front-line leaders.
_________________
"Rangers Lead the Way"
18Z, 11B4X
"The last thing that I want to do is to hurt you,...................... but it's still on the list."
Claymore- Special Member
- Posts : 2852
Join date : 2013-05-17
Location : Northern Mississippi
Re: If you could have a outpost your way what would you want it to look like?
Claymore wrote: Now was this, alone, the factor that pushed Rangers over the cliff? No, but it was one more unnecessary problem that could have been avoided, with a little bit of wisdom, foresight, and humility.......and listening to your front-line leaders.
The lack of listening to your front-line leaders has been endemic for decades. I think we've had 4 national commanders since the passing of Johnnie Barnes. Under one of the first two, Urban Rangers was started. It was a miserable failure. Why? Because big-city RR leaders resented having a "label" attached to them. They just wanted to be regular Rangers like the rest of us.
joecool- VIP Member
- Posts : 3503
Join date : 2013-10-28
Age : 70
Re: If you could have a outpost your way what would you want it to look like?
Claymore wrote:
He successfully drove off much of the talent of the Level I Leaders in the Program.
A few years ago, I called a National Muzzleloading Instructor to set up certification training. When I told him that it was for a Royal Ranger Outpost, he said, "Royal Rangers. Oh yeah, I used to be a Royal Rangers Commander. I could handle the changes under Mariott, but not this current fella (Doug Marsh).".
Just look at what was lost in this man, alone. He was worth THOUSANDS of dollars in training. You know that when he was a commander, he was teaching the boys for free (and it is very likely that he was certifying other commanders through Royal Rangers, for free).
Instead, now he is gone. If you want to get your boys through a course, it is $80.00 to $100.00 for each, and $400.00 to $700.00 to get the men certified as instructors.
Another example of "PENNY-WISE AND POUND-FOOLISH".
_________________
"Rangers Lead the Way"
18Z, 11B4X
"The last thing that I want to do is to hurt you,...................... but it's still on the list."
Claymore- Special Member
- Posts : 2852
Join date : 2013-05-17
Location : Northern Mississippi
Re: If you could have a outpost your way what would you want it to look like?
Sadly, Doug Marsh did so much damage to Rangers. So many"Spirit led changes" of things that were a spirit lead change a year ago & failed miserably. None of it was spirit led, it was all profit led. Doug Marsh treated the men & women who volunteered thier time to Royal Rangers with contempt.
A lot of folks were initially blind to it. Those of us who weren't blind, were called "worldly commanders" & "against kids getting closer to God" & other things. We just needed to get on board or get off the bus.
Well.. Doug Marsh got his wish. a lot of Commanders got off the bus & Rangers is the worse for it.
Back in 2010 there were at least 20 outposts in Michigan. Today there are 6.
THAT is the legacy of Doug Marsh.
And for his tremendous success in destroying Royal Rangers, he got promoted to Director of international ministries at the AG
A lot of folks were initially blind to it. Those of us who weren't blind, were called "worldly commanders" & "against kids getting closer to God" & other things. We just needed to get on board or get off the bus.
Well.. Doug Marsh got his wish. a lot of Commanders got off the bus & Rangers is the worse for it.
Back in 2010 there were at least 20 outposts in Michigan. Today there are 6.
THAT is the legacy of Doug Marsh.
And for his tremendous success in destroying Royal Rangers, he got promoted to Director of international ministries at the AG
_________________
Chris
Former Commander
MI Outpost 97 2008-2016
Claymore likes this post
Re: If you could have a outpost your way what would you want it to look like?
ccm2361 wrote: Those of us who weren't blind, were called "worldly commanders" & "against kids getting closer to God" & other things.
Many of the loudest cheerleaders of Doug Marsh's "spirit led" vision for Rangers are still there at the highest levels of the program. They are just as guitly as Doug Marsh in my eyes. They did his bidding & suppressed any dissent. Yet, they know Doug Marsh was a disaster for Royal Rangers. But will they admit it?
Most of them should be relieved of their positions for lack of discernment. Some of them did unethical things & 1 or 2 even did illegal things to suppress dissent.
It still kind of burns my biscuits, even after 10 years.
I should add for those that do not know. I did not get off the Rangers bus because of Doug Marsh. I am out because we were shut down by our pastor.
_________________
Chris
Former Commander
MI Outpost 97 2008-2016
Re: If you could have a outpost your way what would you want it to look like?
ccm2361 wrote: I should add for those that do not know. I did not get off the Rangers bus because of Doug Marsh. I am out because we were shut down by our pastor.
I grit my teeth for years during that era. And like you, it was my children's pastor that shut down RR at my church. "Breaking in the New Guy" was ultimately unsuccessful.
So now, you and me and a whole lot of guys are out. I sense that you would jump back in if the opportunity presented itself. Otherwise, why would you still be on Ranger Chat? There are a lot of us scattered throughout the heartland. I probably wouldn't do it, because it would resemble what went on during the COVID shutdown, but what if some of us teamed up and skyped our meetings? A commander in Michigan would teach an Automotive merit to boys in multiple states, along with a commander in Mississippi teaching Aviation, and a commander in Montana showing boys how to survive in the winter.
joecool- VIP Member
- Posts : 3503
Join date : 2013-10-28
Age : 70
Re: If you could have a outpost your way what would you want it to look like?
ccm2361 wrote:ccm2361 wrote: Those of us who weren't blind, were called "worldly commanders" & "against kids getting closer to God" & other things.
Many of the loudest cheerleaders of Doug Marsh's "spirit led" vision for Rangers are still there at the highest levels of the program. They are just as guitly as Doug Marsh in my eyes. They did his bidding & suppressed any dissent. Yet, they know Doug Marsh was a disaster for Royal Rangers. But will they admit it?
Most of them should be relieved of their positions for lack of discernment. Some of them did unethical things & 1 or 2 even did illegal things to suppress dissent.
It still kind of burns my biscuits, even after 10 years.
I should add for those that do not know. I did not get off the Rangers bus because of Doug Marsh. I am out because we were shut down by our pastor.
Chris,
First of all, I did not know that your pastor shut down the Program. You had mentioned how attendance was dwindling, and I had assumed that with lack of attendance and the increasing demands of your job, that the program just shriveled up.
Second thanks, you make me feel better about myself. I had thought that I may have been a bit rough in my criticism, but when I saw Chris (who doesn't have a mean bone in his body) be just as critical, it kind-of gave me a warm-fuzzy feeling about myself.
It is very interesting to note that, if the folks running the original Royal Rangers Forum had been a bit more honest and open-minded, you & Dan might not have seen the need for developing Ranger Chat. Now we may not be quite as big and healthy as we once were, but at least, we haven't been Dead for twelve years, like the other one.
_________________
"Rangers Lead the Way"
18Z, 11B4X
"The last thing that I want to do is to hurt you,...................... but it's still on the list."
Claymore- Special Member
- Posts : 2852
Join date : 2013-05-17
Location : Northern Mississippi
ccm2361 and RRCmdrBennett like this post
Re: If you could have a outpost your way what would you want it to look like?
ccm2361 wrote:
A lot of folks were initially blind to it. Those of us who weren't blind, were called "worldly commanders" & "against kids getting closer to God" & other things. We just needed to get on board or get off the bus.
"TOUCH NOT, GOD'S ANNOINTED"
EVERY time that I have heard those words (or words to that effect) it was someone who was attempting to turn a church into a cult.
(And at my age, I HAVE heard it, at least three times. And every time, the above philosophy proved to be true: So much that when State Headquarters warned a previous pastor here to cool it down, a bit, I heard that pastor declare, in front of the congregation that it, "....is Satan at work. I don't care if it is here in this church, or at State Headquarters....".)
How 'bout that? Cult mentality AND arrogance.
_________________
"Rangers Lead the Way"
18Z, 11B4X
"The last thing that I want to do is to hurt you,...................... but it's still on the list."
Claymore- Special Member
- Posts : 2852
Join date : 2013-05-17
Location : Northern Mississippi
ccm2361 and RRCmdrBennett like this post
Re: If you could have a outpost your way what would you want it to look like?
joecool wrote: I sense that you would jump back in if the opportunity presented itself. Otherwise, why would you still be on Ranger Chat?
I would get back in for sure. There is an outpost 20 minutes away. But to join them would be missing Wednesday night service at my own church. Being a Deacon at my church, going to another church every Wednesday night might not look the best.
As for why do I stick around here? I am the Administrator. I have to stick around or no one is runing the show.
_________________
Chris
Former Commander
MI Outpost 97 2008-2016
Re: If you could have a outpost your way what would you want it to look like?
Claymore wrote:[
Chris,
First of all, I did not know that your pastor shut down the Program. You had mentioned how attendance was dwindling, and I had assumed that with lack of attendance and the increasing demands of your job, that the program just shriveled up.
Second thanks, you make me feel better about myself. I had thought that I may have been a bit rough in my criticism, but when I saw Chris (who doesn't have a mean bone in his body) be just as critical, it kind-of gave me a warm-fuzzy feeling about myself.
It is very interesting to note that, if the folks running the original Royal Rangers Forum had been a bit more honest and open-minded, you & Dan might not have seen the need for developing Ranger Chat. Now we may not be quite as big and healthy as we once were, but at least, we haven't been Dead for twelve years, like the other one.
we got shutdown because we got down to just me & my 2 kids.
I am actually quite low in mercy.
_________________
Chris
Former Commander
MI Outpost 97 2008-2016
Re: If you could have a outpost your way what would you want it to look like?
ccm2361 wrote:joecool wrote: I sense that you would jump back in if the opportunity presented itself. Otherwise, why would you still be on Ranger Chat?
I would get back in for sure. There is an outpost 20 minutes away. But to join them would be missing Wednesday night service at my own church. Being a Deacon at my church, going to another church every Wednesday night might not look the best.
As for why do I stick around here? I am the Administrator. I have to stick around or no one is runing the show.
In my original outpost in the Potomac district in Baltimore we had a deacon from a neighboring A/G church do Wednesday nights with us but attend his own church on Sundays.
_________________
Dan Bennett
Sr Commander (2007-2016)
N Central Area Communications Coord, CI (2016)
Outpost #215, Ohio District :flag:
GMA #83 Potomac Dist-#2366 Nat'l
"Be Ready, It wasn't raining when Noah built the Ark."
FCF Frontiersman 9/91
Free Trapper 2016
Training Seminars/Camps:
LTC LMA 5/94, Ranger Basics 1/05, LTA LMA 5/05, NTC IL 5/09, WCO 10/09, ICS 4/10, RKTC 7/10, Ranger Essentials 8/10, NRMC 10/11,
Outpost Leader Advancement Levels:
LMA-Advanced 10/11, MoE 2012-092
RR v1.0
Lima
Golf
Bravo
RRCmdrBennett- Moderator
- Posts : 3605
Join date : 2013-05-15
Age : 48
Location : Ohio
Re: If you could have a outpost your way what would you want it to look like?
RRCmdrBennett wrote:ccm2361 wrote:joecool wrote: I sense that you would jump back in if the opportunity presented itself. Otherwise, why would you still be on Ranger Chat?
I would get back in for sure. There is an outpost 20 minutes away. But to join them would be missing Wednesday night service at my own church. Being a Deacon at my church, going to another church every Wednesday night might not look the best.
As for why do I stick around here? I am the Administrator. I have to stick around or no one is running the show.
In my original outpost in the Potomac district in Baltimore we had a deacon from a neighboring A/G church do Wednesday nights with us but attend his own church on Sundays.
CHRIS,
I am going to have to agree with Dan, again (Lord, take me now...).
Look, if you have a heart for the Lord and for boys and for working with Rangers, then you are wasting the talents that God has given you, unless you have a REALLY good excuse (and I do not consider avoiding disappointing the Pastor as being such).
You ran an outpost for years. You understand the Program, and you know when to go along with the current from Springfield and when to swim cross-current. No amount of money can take the place of the knowledge that you have gained.
When you are standing before the Lord, and he asks what you did with that time and very special talent and experience that he gave to you, and how many boys you helped with it, do you want to say, "Well, none after 2019, but I kept my pastor happy..."?.
A GOOD pastor should understand that if you have a calling for a mission field, especially with young people, that he should be prepared to make accommodations for it. Let him know that you'll be more than happy to keep your talent "at home" if the church comes up with the kids.
It should be like if you had a talent for helping people through Teen Challenge or Celebrate Recovery. Are you going to deny them your help, just because they are across Town, and not walking into your church?
Maybe that will put a flame under your pastor to get more families with kids. Would it work out to take other kids from your church to the place with R/R meetings (this might draw more families with kids to your church and increase Wednesdays and Sundays).
Here at our church, a man who was the captain of the Greeting Team and was the lead male singer in our Worship Team left our church, about 3 weeks ago, because our church didn't have a Youth Group for his girls. I don't hold it against him. Those girls are the center of his universe, and he wants them to enjoy going to church, so he went to a place that has a great Youth Group.
If you are putting in extra time and work to help kids, whether at home or across Town, it is a good thing. The pastor may have been given authority, but that authority is only as much as the congregation gives to him. And do you know what I call someone whose wages are paid out of my pocket? An employee.
_________________
"Rangers Lead the Way"
18Z, 11B4X
"The last thing that I want to do is to hurt you,...................... but it's still on the list."
Claymore- Special Member
- Posts : 2852
Join date : 2013-05-17
Location : Northern Mississippi
RRCmdrBennett likes this post
Re: If you could have a outpost your way what would you want it to look like?
Claymore wrote:
I am going to have to agree with Dan, again (Lord, take me now...).
Claymore wrote: Look, if you have a heart for the Lord and for boys and for working with Rangers, then you are wasting the talents that God has given you, unless you have a REALLY good excuse (and I do not consider avoiding disappointing the Pastor as being such).
Fair point. I will give it some prayer
_________________
Chris
Former Commander
MI Outpost 97 2008-2016
Claymore and joecool like this post
Re: If you could have a outpost your way what would you want it to look like?
Claymore wrote:.RRCmdrBennett wrote:ccm2361 wrote:joecool wrote: I sense that you would jump back in if the opportunity presented itself. Otherwise, why would you still be on Ranger Chat?
I would get back in for sure. There is an outpost 20 minutes away. But to join them would be missing Wednesday night service at my own church. Being a Deacon at my church, going to another church every Wednesday night might not look the best.
As for why do I stick around here? I am the Administrator. I have to stick around or no one is running the show.
In my original outpost in the Potomac district in Baltimore we had a deacon from a neighboring A/G church do Wednesday nights with us but attend his own church on Sundays.
CHRIS,
I am going to have to agree with Dan, again (Lord, take me now...).
Look, if you have a heart for the Lord and for boys and for working with Rangers, then you are wasting the talents that God has given you, unless you have a REALLY good excuse (and I do not consider avoiding disappointing the Pastor as being such).
You ran an outpost for years. You understand the Program, and you know when to go along with the current from Springfield and when to swim cross-current. No amount of money can take the place of the knowledge that you have gained.
When you are standing before the Lord, and he asks what you did with that time and very special talent and experience that he gave to you, and how many boys you helped with it, do you want to say, "Well, none after 2019, but I kept my pastor happy..."?.
A GOOD pastor should understand that if you have a calling for a mission field, especially with young people, that he should be prepared to make accommodations for it. Let him know that you'll be more than happy to keep your talent "at home" if the church comes up with the kids.
It should be like if you had a talent for helping people through Teen Challenge or Celebrate Recovery. Are you going to deny them your help, just because they are across Town, and not walking into your church?
Maybe that will put a flame under your pastor to get more families with kids. Would it work out to take other kids from your church to the place with R/R meetings (this might draw more families with kids to your church and increase Wednesdays and Sundays).
Here at our church, a man who was the captain of the Greeting Team and was the lead male singer in our Worship Team left our church, about 3 weeks ago, because our church didn't have a Youth Group for his girls. I don't hold it against him. Those girls are the center of his universe, and he wants them to enjoy going to church, so he went to a place that has a great Youth Group.
If you are putting in extra time and work to help kids, whether at home or across Town, it is a good thing. The pastor may have been given authority, but that authority is only as much as the congregation gives to him. And do you know what I call someone whose wages are paid out of my pocket? An employee.
Even a broke clock is right twice a day I will mark this day on my calendar!
_________________
Dan Bennett
Sr Commander (2007-2016)
N Central Area Communications Coord, CI (2016)
Outpost #215, Ohio District :flag:
GMA #83 Potomac Dist-#2366 Nat'l
"Be Ready, It wasn't raining when Noah built the Ark."
FCF Frontiersman 9/91
Free Trapper 2016
Training Seminars/Camps:
LTC LMA 5/94, Ranger Basics 1/05, LTA LMA 5/05, NTC IL 5/09, WCO 10/09, ICS 4/10, RKTC 7/10, Ranger Essentials 8/10, NRMC 10/11,
Outpost Leader Advancement Levels:
LMA-Advanced 10/11, MoE 2012-092
RR v1.0
Lima
Golf
Bravo
RRCmdrBennett- Moderator
- Posts : 3605
Join date : 2013-05-15
Age : 48
Location : Ohio
Claymore likes this post
Re: If you could have a outpost your way what would you want it to look like?
Claymore wrote:
Look, if you have a heart for the Lord and for boys and for working with Rangers, then you are wasting the talents that God has given you, unless you have a REALLY good excuse (and I do not consider avoiding disappointing the Pastor as being such).
I have thought about it. I miss Rangers but I am learning a lot on Wednesday nights. I am going to leave it up to the Lord. I asked for 2 signs. If I see them, then I will know that
is where He wants me.
_________________
Chris
Former Commander
MI Outpost 97 2008-2016
Re: If you could have a outpost your way what would you want it to look like?
ccm2361 wrote: I asked for 2 signs. If I see them, then I will know that
is where He wants me.
Well, HERE's ONE sign for you:
Now, He only has to provide One more...............
_________________
"Rangers Lead the Way"
18Z, 11B4X
"The last thing that I want to do is to hurt you,...................... but it's still on the list."
Claymore- Special Member
- Posts : 2852
Join date : 2013-05-17
Location : Northern Mississippi
Page 2 of 2 • 1, 2
Similar topics
» Big changes come to our Outpost
» Ranger Derby on the Outpost level!
» First Outpost Level Winter Camp 2016
» Outpost Trail Options
» Time for a big change in our Outpost
» Ranger Derby on the Outpost level!
» First Outpost Level Winter Camp 2016
» Outpost Trail Options
» Time for a big change in our Outpost
Page 2 of 2
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum